Projects found only on
MilitaryCity.com

[Faces of Valor]
[Forums]
[Shootout 2004]
Images from
Iraqi Freedom and
Enduring Freedom
Honor the fallen
Memorial to those killed

Discussions on our stories
and other hot topics

We test the latest weapons,
ammunition and other products
for the military market

Nominate an Everyday Hero
2006 Winners Announced!
Nominate an Everyday Hero
Nominate an Everyday Hero
Nominate an Everyday Hero
Nominate an Everyday Hero
Nominate an Everyday Hero
 Published:
 January 3, 2005

Back

We asked what you think.
You told us.
continued

 2004 Poll
How we did it

On Nov. 8, we mailed questionnaires to 6,000 people drawn at random from our subscriber list. Recipients were asked to mail their answers to an independent firm that machine-tabulated the results to guarantee anonymity. We stopped processing incoming questionnaires Dec. 20.

About 4,300 of the 6,000 people who received questionnaires turned out to be on active duty. Of those, 1,423 responded, a 33 percent response rate. The margin of error in the survey is plus or minus 2.6 percent.

Those polled differ from the military as a whole in important ways. They tend to be older, higher in rank and more career-oriented. Even so, it is perhaps the most representative independent sample possible because of the inherent challenges in polling servicemen and women, according to polling experts and military sociologists.

The poll has come to be viewed by some as a barometer of the professional career military.


More stories
• Women’s, men’s views differ on war and Bush
• Most opposed to publishing negative war news

Poll results
• Morale
• War, Iraq and President Bush
• Civilian/Military Gap
• Race, Gender Gay
• Miscellanious

“While the military might make criticisms … they remain committed to the enterprise and optimistic that they’ll see it through to victory.”

Feaver sees no “Iraq syndrome akin to the Vietnam syndrome,” marked by alienation from both the war and its leadership.

He says the military today believes “defeat (in Iraq) would be awful and victory is possible and that leads to the staying power you’re seeing. … It’s reflecting a war-time survey of a military that still thinks it can win. … When the military thinks it can’t win, that’s bad news.”

Survey respondents also were clear about the idea of a military draft: They don’t like it.

In addition to the 75 percent who said men should not be drafted, 83 percent rejected the idea of compulsory service for women, and 73 percent said returning to the draft would lower the quality of the force.

Nearly as many, 65 percent, said a draft would make it harder to maintain discipline.

Mostly satisfied

In terms of job satisfaction, the military is comparable to the civilian world. In our poll, 37 percent of service members said they were completely satisfied and another 50 percent said they were somewhat satisfied. Among civilians, those numbers reverse, with 50 percent saying they are completely satisfied and 39 percent somewhat satisfied.

The aspect of military life that drew the most complaints: housing, with a quarter of respondents saying their military housing was poor or very poor.

But there’s no escaping other areas of concern. When asked who should be held accountable for shortages of body armor among deployed troops, respondents gave Congress the biggest share of the blame, 60 percent. But 49 percent said senior military officials also should be held accountable. Only 35 percent laid blame on the Bush administration.

Similarly, most respondents don’t believe responsibility for the abuse of Iraqi prisoners at Abu Ghraib should run uphill.

Respondents were asked to check boxes alongside as many different groups as they thought should be punished for the abuse. Some 74 percent thought the soldiers who committed the abuse should be punished and 67 percent said the officer in direct command of the prison should be punished.

But only 21 percent said high-level military commanders should be held accountable, and even fewer — 12 percent — thought civilian policymakers should share in the blame. The president, meanwhile, was almost blame-free: Only 3 percent named Bush.

Staff writers Joe Chennelly, Bruce Rolfsen, Mark Faram, Gordon Lubold and freelancer Jodi Upton contributed to this report.

 
Use of this site signifies your agreement to the Terms of Service (Updated 10 January 2003)